Skip to main content

Who Does AI Recommend Locally? 240 Answers Tested

9 min read
Bar chart of which source types ChatGPT, Google AI Mode and Gemini cited across 240 local service answers
We sent 80 local service questions to ChatGPT, Google AI Mode and Gemini on November 19, 2026, and counted every source link shown with the 240 answers. Of the 1,363 sources cited, 75.8% were business websites and 13.9% were directories or review sites. ChatGPT cited a directory in 61 of its 80 answers, Google AI Mode in 18 and Gemini in 23. The engines seldom linked to the same companies: 77.4% of the business websites cited for a question were cited by only one engine. This is one run on one day, and the numbers will differ on another day.

Limits of this test

  • One run on one day, November 19, 2026. Results will differ on another day.
  • 80 questions sent to ChatGPT, Google AI Mode and Gemini. Perplexity was not tested because our data provider returned no Perplexity answers that day.
  • Every question named a Sacramento-region city: Sacramento, Roseville, Rocklin or Folsom.
  • A citation is a source link shown with an answer. Businesses named in the text without a link were not counted.

AEO (answer engine optimization) and GEO (generative engine optimization) are two names for the work of getting a business mentioned in AI answers. This report shows what the engines linked to and makes no claims about why. No local business is named. Directories, forums and government sites are named, because they are the same for every business.

Key Findings

  • Business websites were 75.8% of cited sources: 1,033 of 1,363 citations.
  • Directories and review sites were 13.9%: 189 citations, 144 of them from ChatGPT.
  • ChatGPT cited a directory or review site in 61 of 80 answers. Google AI Mode did in 18 and Gemini in 23.
  • 77.4% of business websites cited for a question were cited by only one engine. All three engines agreed 19 times out of 827.
  • Median source links per answer: 8 for ChatGPT, 6 for Google AI Mode and 2 for Gemini.
  • Yelp was the most-cited directory, with 32 citations. The California contractor license board's site was cited 18 times, all by ChatGPT.

Verlua helps customers find your business in Google and AI answers. AI search work is part of our SEO, from $1,000/mo. Month to month, with no minimum contract.

Where Do AI Answers Get Local Business Recommendations?

In these 240 answers, most cited sources were the businesses' own websites. Business websites made up 75.8% of the 1,363 citations. Directories and review sites made up 13.9%, government and utility sites 6.1%, forums and social sites 1.2%, and everything else 3.1%.

Share of the 1,363 cited sources by type, all three engines
Business websites75.8% (1,033)
Directories and review sites13.9% (189)
Government and utilities6.1% (83)
Forums and social1.2% (16)
Other3.1% (42)

Source: Verlua test, November 19, 2026.

Cited sources by type across ChatGPT, Google AI Mode and Gemini: citations, share of all citations and number of different sites
Source typeCitationsShare of citationsDifferent sites
Business websites1,03375.8%518
Directories and review sites18913.9%55
Government and utilities836.1%34
Forums and social161.2%4
Other423.1%36
All sources1,363100%647

Source: Verlua test, November 19, 2026. Shares are rounded, so the rows add to 100.1%.

The 1,033 business-website citations were spread across 518 different sites. Of those, 301 were cited exactly once, and 39 were cited five or more times. The most-cited one appeared in 13 of the 240 answers. A "business website" here is a local or franchise company's own site.

Do ChatGPT, Google AI Mode and Gemini Cite the Same Sources?

No. In this test ChatGPT showed the most links (696 across 80 answers, a median of 8 per answer) and cited directories most often. Google AI Mode leaned hardest on business websites, at 88.4% of its citations. Gemini showed the fewest links, a median of 2 per answer.

Answers, citations, median links per answer and share of citations by source type for ChatGPT, Google AI Mode and Gemini
MeasureChatGPTGoogle AI ModeGemini
Answers808080
Answers that showed source links807771
Citations696447220
Median links per answer862
Business websites66.5%88.4%79.5%
Directories and review sites20.7%4.5%11.4%
Government and utilities7.5%4.3%5.5%
Forums and social1.1%1.3%0.9%
Other4.2%1.6%2.7%
Answers citing a directory or review site61 of 8018 of 8023 of 80
Answers citing a business website79 of 8071 of 8065 of 80

Source: Verlua test, November 19, 2026. Percent rows are each engine's share of its own citations.

Counted by answer, at least one directory or review site was cited in 102 of the 240 answers, and 61 of those were ChatGPT answers. Twelve answers showed no source links at all: 3 from Google AI Mode and 9 from Gemini. AI Mode is one of the AI features in Google Search and is separate from AI Overviews, which this test did not measure.

Do the Engines Recommend the Same Businesses?

Mostly no, going by the business websites each engine linked to. For each question we listed every business website cited by any engine, which gave 827 question-and-site pairs. Of those, 640 (77.4%) were cited by one engine only. Another 187 were cited by two or more engines, and 19 of the 187 by all three.

By question, at least one business website was cited by two engines in 69 of the 80 questions, and by all three in 16. In the other 11, no two engines cited the same business website.

So a company linked by one engine was usually absent from the other two engines' links for the same question. Names mentioned without a link are not part of this comparison.

Which Directories and Public Sites Showed Up Most?

Yelp was the most-cited directory in this test, with 32 citations. That combines yelp.com (25) and its mobile address m.yelp.com (7), counted as one site. Next came the California Contractors State License Board with 18, Thumbtack and Angi with 15 each, and Expertise.com with 12.

Most-cited directories, forums and public sites in the test, with citations by engine
SiteCitationsChatGPTGoogle AI ModeGemini
Yelp (yelp.com and m.yelp.com)Directory3221110
California Contractors State License Board (cslb.ca.gov)Government181800
ThumbtackDirectory151032
AngiDirectory15618
Expertise.comDirectory121200
BestProsInTown (bestprosintown.com)Directory9900
City of Folsom (folsom.ca.us)Government8242
RedditForum7142
Better Business Bureau (bbb.org)Directory7610
Birdeye reviews (reviews.birdeye.com)Directory7700
NextdoorForum6600
City of Roseville (roseville.ca.gov)Government6222
HouzzDirectory6105
California DMV (dmv.ca.gov)Government6321
California Department of Insurance (insurance.ca.gov)Government6312

Source: Verlua test, November 19, 2026. A site is counted once per answer. Business websites are left out.

Several sites were cited by one engine only. The license board, Expertise.com, BestProsInTown, Birdeye's review pages and Nextdoor were cited by ChatGPT alone. Houzz got 5 of its 6 citations from Gemini. Yelp was never cited by Gemini.

Does the Question Wording Change the Sources?

A little, in this test. Half the questions asked for the best company, such as "best electrician in Folsom CA". The other half described a problem, such as "who should I call for an electrical panel upgrade in Folsom CA". Business websites were about three quarters of citations either way.

Share of citations by source type for the two question wordings used in the test
Measure"Best <trade> in <city>""Who should I call for <problem> in <city>"
Answers120120
Citations700663
Business websites75.3%76.3%
Directories and review sites17.7%9.8%
Government and utilities2.7%9.7%
Forums and social1.3%1.1%
Other3.0%3.2%

Source: Verlua test, November 19, 2026. Percent rows are the share of that wording's citations.

Directories and review sites were 17.7% of citations on "best" questions and 9.8% on problem questions. Government and utility sites went the other way: 2.7% and 9.7%. Only these two wordings were tested.

Does It Differ by Trade?

Yes, somewhat. Business websites were the largest cited group in all ten trades, from 54.1% of citations for personal injury lawyers to 85.0% for tree services. Directory share ran from 6.1% for tree services to 18.5% for personal injury lawyers. Each trade has only 24 answers, so read the rows as rough.

Citations and share by source type for each of the ten trades in the test
TradeCitationsBusiness websitesDirectories and review sitesGovernment and utilities
Roofer13576.3%15.6%4.4%
Plumber13667.6%16.9%9.6%
HVAC company13974.1%16.5%2.9%
Electrician14371.3%16.1%7.7%
Pest control company12281.1%12.3%2.5%
Landscaper13581.5%10.4%1.5%
Tree service14785.0%6.1%8.8%
House cleaning service14782.3%14.3%0.0%
Dentist12484.7%12.1%0.8%
Personal injury lawyer13554.1%18.5%22.2%

Source: Verlua test, November 19, 2026. 24 answers per trade. Forums and other sites are not shown, so rows do not add to 100%.

The personal injury lawyer row stands apart, with the lowest business-website share (54.1%) and the highest government share (22.2%). For contractors, the site to note is the California Contractors State License Board (cslb.ca.gov). It was cited 18 times, in 18 different questions, always by ChatGPT. We counted sites and did not record pages, so we can't say which of its pages were linked.

What Should a Local Business Do With This?

Start with your own website, because business websites were the most-cited source type in this test. Then check the directories that appeared and, for contractors, the license board record. Expect each engine to answer differently, and track a fixed list of questions. None of this guarantees a citation.

  • Put the basics on your service pages in text. Business websites were 75.8% of citations. This test did not examine the cited pages, so it can't say which page features matter. A sensible baseline: each service page states what the service is, which towns you cover and how to reach you. Our guide on how a business gets cited by ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews covers the page work.
  • Check the directories that appeared. ChatGPT cited a directory or review site in 61 of 80 answers. Yelp, Thumbtack, Angi and Expertise.com were cited most. Where one fits your trade and lets you claim or edit a listing, make sure its name, address, phone and services match your website. Whether a listing causes a citation is a question this test can't answer.
  • Contractors: check your license board record. ChatGPT cited the California license board's site 18 times. A California contractor's public license record is on that site, so check that it is current and that the business name matches your website.
  • Track a fixed list of questions on each engine. All three engines agreed on 19 of 827 cited business websites, so one answer from one engine is a weak signal. Ask each engine the same short list of customer questions once a month, and record which companies and sources appear.

If you would rather hand this off, Verlua does this work as part of SEO: answer-first pages, AI crawler access, consistent listings and a plain-English monthly report. SEO starts at $1,000/mo, about $1,500/mo in competitive industries, month to month with no minimum contract. See the AI search service or contact our team. No agency can promise a citation. If you are still deciding, read whether an AEO agency is worth it.

How Was the Test Run, and What Are Its Limits?

We wrote 80 questions from 10 trades, 4 cities and 2 wordings. Each was sent once to ChatGPT, Google AI Mode and Gemini on November 19, 2026, through a third-party data provider, with a US location and no login or personalization.

  • Trades: roofer, plumber, HVAC company, electrician, pest control company, landscaper, tree service, house cleaning service, dentist and personal injury lawyer.
  • Cities: Sacramento, Roseville, Rocklin and Folsom, California.
  • Wordings: "best <trade> in <city>" and "who should I call for <problem> in <city>", for example "who should I call for a burst pipe in Roseville CA".
  • Counting: the links each engine attached to its answer, reduced to the site address and counted once per answer.
  • Sorting: a hand-built list put each site into one of five types: directories and review sites, government and utilities (including city sites and the contractor license board), forums and social, other (real estate portals, manufacturers, press-release and news sites) and business websites (everything left).

Read the numbers with these limits in mind:

  • One run on one day. AI answers change between runs, so another day will give different numbers.
  • Perplexity was not tested. Our data provider returned no Perplexity answers on the run date.
  • Sacramento-region questions only. Other regions and trades may look different.
  • Links only. A link shown with an answer is not the same as every business named in the text.
  • Hand sorting. A few miscellaneous sites may remain in the business website group.
  • No page review. We did not examine the cited pages, so this test says nothing about why a source was cited.

A disclosure: Verlua is an SEO agency and sells AI search work. None of the questions were about agencies, and verlua.com was cited 0 times.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Study

Which AI engines did this study test?

ChatGPT, Google AI Mode and Gemini. Each received the same 80 local service questions once on November 19, 2026, which produced 240 answers and 1,363 cited sources. Perplexity is not included because our data provider returned no Perplexity answers that day.

Where do AI answers get local business recommendations?

In these 240 answers, 75.8% of cited sources were business websites. Directories and review sites were 13.9%, government and utility sites 6.1%, forums and social sites 1.2%, and other sites 3.1%. These are links shown with answers on one day, for Sacramento-region questions.

Do ChatGPT and Google recommend the same local businesses?

Not often, going by the links in this test. Of 827 cases where a business website was cited for a question, 77.4% were cited by only one of the three engines, and 19 were cited by all three. Businesses named in the text without a link were not counted.

Does a Yelp listing help a business show up in AI answers?

This test cannot answer that. Yelp was the most-cited directory in these 240 answers, with 32 citations: 21 from ChatGPT, 11 from Google AI Mode and none from Gemini. That shows which directory the engines linked to. It does not show that a listing causes a recommendation.

Will the results be the same for my city, or next month?

Probably not exactly. This was one run on one day about four Sacramento-region cities, and AI answers change between runs. Treat the numbers as a snapshot. For your own picture, ask each engine a fixed list of customer questions about your trade and town every month.

Find out whether AI tools can read your website

Start with Verlua's free AI visibility check. It tests whether AI crawlers can reach and read your site, then lists what to fix. To have the work done for you, AI search is part of our SEO, from $1,000/mo, about $1,500/mo in competitive industries. Month to month, with no minimum contract.

Share:
MS
Mark Shvaya

Founder & Technical Director

Mark Shvaya runs Verlua, a web design and development studio in Sacramento. He builds and runs websites and SEO for local service businesses, from gutter and tree crews to glass and painting companies.

Founder & Technical Director at Verlua. Leads the websites, AI workflows and SEO work.

Stay in Touch

Leave your email and we may send you new guides on web development, AI, and digital strategy.

No spam. Ask us to remove you anytime at support@verlua.com.

Related Articles

Explore Related Content

Related Services

Book a 30-minute call

Let’s get you a personalized response

Tell us a bit about your business and our team will be in touch within one business day.

By submitting, you agree we can contact you about this request, and to our privacy policy. Text and marketing consent above is optional.