Skip to main content

How to Choose an AEO or GEO Agency: 9 Questions

10 min read
Two people at a table in a small contractor office going through a notebook of questions
To choose an AEO or GEO agency, look for four things that separate a real offer from an SEO package with a new label. The agency names the pages and fixes it will make on your site. It tracks a fixed list of questions your customers ask, in each AI tool, every month. It reports AI referral traffic and leads next to your Google clicks. It also tells you plainly that it can't promise a citation. AEO (answer engine optimization) and GEO (generative engine optimization) both mean helping tools like ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews name and link your business.

TL;DR

Ask nine questions before you sign. They cover the work on your site, the tracking and reporting, ownership, the contract, the price and the proof. Expect an audit and tracking in month one. Treat "best agencies" lists as a starting shortlist.

Get found by customers on Google and in AI answers. Verlua does the AI search work as part of SEO, from $1,000/mo. No minimum contract.

If you're still deciding whether to pay anyone, read whether an AEO agency is worth it. For prices, see what AEO and GEO services cost. For the terms, see AEO vs GEO vs SEO.

How Do You Choose an AEO or GEO Agency?

Choose the agency that can tell you, before you sign, what it will change on your site, which customer questions it will track, how it will report results and what it won't promise. Skill matters, but you can't test skill in a sales call. You can test whether the answers are specific.

Two terms first. An AI Overview is the AI-written summary Google shows above some search results. A citation is when an AI answer names your business or links to your page as a source.

Google's guide to hiring an SEO now covers these services. It suggests asking whether an agency's advice on "AEO" or "GEO" lines up with Google's official guidance on optimizing for generative AI features. Google's AI features documentation says SEO best practices remain relevant for AI Overviews and AI Mode, Google's chat-style search, with no additional requirements. A real offer is therefore good SEO plus a short list of specific extras.

What Questions Should You Ask an AEO or GEO Agency?

Ask nine questions. They cover what changes on your site, which questions get tracked, how results are reported, who owns the accounts, the contract, what isn't promised, how the work fits with SEO, the price and the proof. Ask by email if you can, because written answers are easier to compare across agencies.

1. What will you change on my website?

AI tools can only cite pages they can read. A crawler is the program a search engine or AI tool uses to read your pages, and OpenAI's crawler documentation says sites that opt out of its OAI-SearchBot crawler won't be shown in ChatGPT search answers.

What a good answer sounds like

"In month one we check that Google and the AI search crawlers can read your site. Then we rewrite your main service pages so each question heading is followed by a direct answer. You see the page list first."

What to be careful of

Answers that never name a page, or a deliverable that is mostly a dashboard login while the site itself doesn't change.

2. How do you pick the questions you track?

AI answers can't be tracked like Google rankings. Agencies check a set list of questions, often called prompts, in each AI tool and record whether your business is named. The list should come from what your customers ask before they hire, by service and by area.

What a good answer sounds like

"We build the list with you from sales calls, emails and your Search Console searches. It stays fixed so months can be compared, and it includes questions where you don't show up yet."

What to be careful of

Lists made mostly of your business name. An AI tool asked about a business by name will usually answer about that business, which says little about new customers finding you.

3. How do you report AI citations and AI referral traffic?

Ask for a sample report. AI referral traffic means visits that arrive from a link inside an AI tool. Google Analytics has a default AI Assistant channel for sources like ChatGPT, Gemini and Copilot. It excludes Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode, whose clicks are counted inside the Web totals of Search Console's Performance report.

What a good answer sounds like

"You get one monthly report: AI referral visits from Analytics, Search Console clicks on the pages we changed, the question list results in each AI tool, and leads who said they found you through AI."

What to be careful of

A single screenshot of one AI answer, which can differ the next day or for the next person. Also a "visibility score" nobody can explain. Google says it doesn't evaluate or endorse third-party SEO tools.

4. Who owns the website, the accounts and the content?

You should own the domain, the website, your Google Business Profile, Search Console, Analytics and everything written for you. Google's third-party policy for Business Profiles says a business must keep ownership or co-ownership of its profile at all times. It also says an agency must let the business regain exclusive control within 7 business days of being asked.

What a good answer sounds like

"Everything is in your accounts and we're added as a manager. If you leave, you remove our access and keep everything."

What to be careful of

A site on the agency's own platform that can't be moved, a Business Profile created under the agency's login, or content you only license while you keep paying.

5. How long is the contract, and how do I leave?

This work takes months to judge, so a fixed term isn't a warning sign by itself. Check that the contract names the work delivered each month and lets you leave if that work isn't delivered.

What a good answer sounds like

"It's month to month." Or: "It's a fixed term with the monthly deliverables written in, and you can leave if we miss them."

What to be careful of

A long term with no monthly deliverables, an automatic renewal you must cancel far in advance, or a fee to get your own accounts back.

6. What will you not promise?

A straight answer here is a good sign. Google's hiring guide says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google, and warns about anyone who claims a "special relationship" with Google. AI answers are no easier to promise: they change with the platform, the wording of the question and the person asking.

What a good answer sounds like

"We can't promise that ChatGPT or an AI Overview will name you. We commit to the work and to a report that shows what changed."

What to be careful of

Guaranteed placement in ChatGPT, a promised number of citations by a set date, or talk of inside access at an AI company.

7. How does this fit with my SEO and Google Business Profile?

It should be one plan. Google says a page must be indexed, meaning stored in Google's database of pages, and eligible to show with a snippet before it can appear as a link in an AI Overview. An agency should check those basics before it sells anything AI-specific. For a local business, they include the Business Profile and matching business details everywhere you're listed.

What a good answer sounds like

"We look at Google first. If your pages aren't indexed or your Business Profile is thin, we fix that before the AI-specific work."

What to be careful of

AI-only work while Google can't index the site, a plan that ignores your Business Profile, or advice to stop regular SEO.

8. How is the price built?

Ask what the monthly fee covers, whether the first months cost more, and whether AI work is a separate fee on top of SEO. Either structure can be fair. Because the work overlaps with SEO, a second retainer should list exactly what it adds. Google says you don't need new machine-readable files or AI text files to appear in its AI features, so a small file shouldn't be a large line item.

What a good answer sounds like

"It's one monthly price with the work listed. Setup months cost more because the audit and fixes happen then."

What to be careful of

A second retainer for work your SEO provider already does. Also a fee for "managing" your Google Business Profile with no mention that the profile is free, which Google requires agencies to disclose.

9. Can you show me a site you work on and what changed?

Google's hiring guide suggests asking for examples of previous work and checking references. Dated Search Console or Analytics data for a named site is solid evidence of search results. Proof of AI citations is newer and harder to show, and an honest agency will say which of the two it has.

What a good answer sounds like

"Here is a named site, the date range, the data source and the work we did. This chart is Google clicks, and here is how the question list results moved."

What to be careful of

Results with no dates or source, and any citation claim you can't reproduce by asking the AI tool the same question yourself.

Google Search Console performance report for colfaxglass.com, March 29 to September 28, 2026: 1.81K total clicks, 258K total impressions, 0.7% average CTR, average position 19.3. Daily clicks rise from near zero in April to mostly between 10 and 35 a day from late June on.
What dated proof looks like: the Search Console performance report for colfaxglass.com, a site we built, Mar 29 – Sep 28, 2026. These are Google search clicks and impressions, not leads or AI citations.

What Should an AEO or GEO Agency Deliver in the First 3 Months?

In month one, expect an audit, your customer questions asked in each AI tool, and tracking set up. In months two and three, expect the foundation fixes finished and the first pages rewritten. After that, expect more pages, mentions on other sites and a monthly report. The table uses Verlua's own process, from our AI SEO service page, as the example.

Deliverables to expect from an AEO or GEO agency by month, using Verlua's process as the example
WhenWhat you should receiveHow to check it
Month 1A week-one audit of crawler access, indexing, schema, page structure and business listings. Your customer questions, asked in each AI tool. AI referral tracking in Google Analytics.Ask to see the audit findings and the answers each AI tool gave. AI referral traffic shows as its own channel in your Analytics account.
Months 2 to 3Crawler and indexing fixes, schema, an llms.txt file and listings cleanup finished. The first service pages rewritten with the answer first.Open the rewritten pages. Each question heading is followed by a direct answer.
OngoingMore pages rewritten or added each month, plus mentions on trusted local and trade sites. A monthly report with AI referral visits, Search Console clicks, question list results, leads and next month’s priorities.Each report lists what shipped and compares the same question list with the month before.

Source: Verlua's AI SEO service page. At Verlua the foundation work happens in launch months, usually the first 2, and the split between month 1 and months 2 to 3 depends on what the audit finds. Schema is code that labels your business details for search engines. An llms.txt file is a text file that points AI tools to your main pages.

Any agency you consider should be able to fill in a table like this before you sign. Mentions are in the last row because AI answers lean on sources people already trust. See our study of which sources AI engines cite for local service recommendations.

Can You Trust "Best AEO Agencies" and "Best AI SEO Agencies" Lists?

Use them as a starting shortlist and check the claims yourself. When we checked the search results on November 19, 2026, some of these lists were published by an agency that also appears on the list, sometimes in first place. Others came from software companies. Some explained how they ranked the agencies and some didn't.

Publishing a list you appear on doesn't make it wrong, and some publishers say so openly. It does mean the order tells you little. The FTC's endorsement guidance covers paid or connected endorsements. It's a good habit to look for a disclosure note either way.

To verify a claim on a list:

  • Check who published it. See whether the publisher is on the list and whether the page says so.
  • Look for a method. A list that states how agencies were chosen gives you something to test.
  • Test one claim per agency. If a list says an agency got a client cited in ChatGPT, ask the agency for the client, the question and the date. Then ask the AI tool that question yourself.
  • Call a reference. Google's hiring guide suggests asking past clients whether the service was useful and produced results.

Is Verlua the Right AEO or GEO Agency for Your Business?

Verlua fits a service business that wins work through search, owns its website or wants it rebuilt, and has someone answering calls and forms quickly. We work with businesses anywhere in the US. Verlua doesn't fit a business that wants a guaranteed ChatGPT placement, or one that wants AI-only work while Google can't index the site.

Here is how we answer our own questions. The work is listed on the AI SEO service page. It's priced as SEO with no separate AI fee: from $1,000/mo, about $1,500/mo in competitive industries, and about $2,500/mo in launch months with heavy setup. Billing is month to month with no minimum contract. Your site, profiles and analytics stay in your accounts.

On proof, we don't publish AI citation results yet. We can show Google search data. Sacramento Gutter Guard, a site we built and run SEO for, went from 60 to 776 Google clicks over the same 12 weeks a year apart (Jul 27–Oct 18, 2025 vs Jul 26–Oct 17, 2026). That's Google search data, not ChatGPT traffic. We have also claimed and verified ChatGPT Business Hub listings for businesses whose sites and Google profiles we run. More sites are on our results page.

To look before you talk to anyone, run the free AI visibility check on your own site. It's self-serve and tests whether AI crawlers can reach your pages.

Frequently Asked Questions About Choosing an AEO or GEO Agency

What does an AEO or GEO agency do?

An AEO (answer engine optimization) agency helps AI tools such as ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews find, understand and cite your business. A GEO (generative engine optimization) agency does much the same work under another name. Most of it happens on your own site and listings: crawler access, direct answers under question headings, consistent business details, mentions on trusted sites and AI referral tracking.

How much does an AEO or GEO agency cost?

It depends on the scope and on whether the AI work is sold separately or inside SEO. Verlua prices it as part of SEO, with no separate AI fee: from $1,000/mo, about $1,500/mo in competitive industries, and about $2,500/mo in launch months with heavy setup. Billing is month to month, with no minimum contract.

Can an agency guarantee my business shows up in ChatGPT or AI Overviews?

No. AI answers change with the platform, the wording of the question and the person asking, so no agency controls them. Google’s guide to hiring an SEO says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google either. An agency can commit to the work and to a monthly report that shows what changed.

How long does AEO or GEO work take to show results?

The setup can be checked within the first month: the audit, crawler access and tracking. OpenAI says its search systems can take about 24 hours to adjust after a change to robots.txt, the file that tells crawlers what they can read. Citations and traffic take longer and vary by business, so judge the trend over several months.

What is the best AEO or AI SEO agency?

There isn’t one best agency for every business. The right one depends on your size, your market and whether you need a website rebuilt as well. Use published lists to build a shortlist. Then ask each agency the same questions about its work, reporting, contract terms and proof, and compare the written answers.

More customers from Google and AI answers, measured every month.

Verlua fixes what Google and AI tools need to read your site, rewrites service pages with the answer first, and reports AI referral traffic, clicks and leads. Priced as SEO, from $1,000/mo. No minimum contract.

Share:
MS
Mark Shvaya

Founder & Technical Director

Mark Shvaya runs Verlua, a web design and development studio in Sacramento. He builds and runs websites and SEO for local service businesses, from gutter and tree crews to glass and painting companies.

Founder & Technical Director at Verlua. Leads the websites, AI workflows and SEO work.

Stay in Touch

Leave your email and we may send you new guides on web development, AI, and digital strategy.

No spam. Ask us to remove you anytime at support@verlua.com.

Related Articles

Explore Related Content

Related Services

Book a 30-minute call

Let’s get you a personalized response

Tell us a bit about your business and our team will be in touch within one business day.

By submitting, you agree we can contact you about this request, and to our privacy policy. Text and marketing consent above is optional.